Why?
Premise: God Exists, therefore God creates World and therefore God creates Life, and therefore God creates Man.
Why was Man created?
In whatever way I choose to look at it, the argument remains circular. Why was "I created? If there is a Cosmic Purpose, and God is omnipotent, why not just jump straight onto the Purpose, why go through the entire process of evolution?
Saying that he made us to "test" us, as per relegion, doesn't stand, because its flawed logic. God creates man--God tests man--but the "test" cant be called a "test" since God created Man and in a way controls all that he does anyway. He couldn't have created man with some "cosmic purpose" and then left everything to Man's "free will" or chance. And if he did, then there is no purpose, for if Man had been given "free will" (if it exists), then Man can't necessairly be heading towards a Purpose ordined by God, for if he does, then he is not really acting in "free will" but in the will of God. SO it can be inferred that a man's "free will" is actually the will of God then it is not, by any definition, "free will".
So the question remains unanswered, Why was Man created?
I want to know. If there is an answer to that, I'm going to search for it.
Why was Man created?
In whatever way I choose to look at it, the argument remains circular. Why was "I created? If there is a Cosmic Purpose, and God is omnipotent, why not just jump straight onto the Purpose, why go through the entire process of evolution?
Saying that he made us to "test" us, as per relegion, doesn't stand, because its flawed logic. God creates man--God tests man--but the "test" cant be called a "test" since God created Man and in a way controls all that he does anyway. He couldn't have created man with some "cosmic purpose" and then left everything to Man's "free will" or chance. And if he did, then there is no purpose, for if Man had been given "free will" (if it exists), then Man can't necessairly be heading towards a Purpose ordined by God, for if he does, then he is not really acting in "free will" but in the will of God. SO it can be inferred that a man's "free will" is actually the will of God then it is not, by any definition, "free will".
So the question remains unanswered, Why was Man created?
I want to know. If there is an answer to that, I'm going to search for it.
posted by Shekure Darashikoh at 11:43 AM
1 Comments:
its all a lie, all a farce. tests, free will; its what stupid people conjure in their free time.
the reason this logic is flawed is because this logic is interpreted, if not created, by humans. i mean, if free will is defined by indulging in 'evil' acts, i.e. looting, plundering, raping, causing harm to fellow human beings, and then you blame it on God's will, is that not capricious?
in any case, the 'test' and the 'free will' are components of a philosophy created for the purpose of man's ethical morality. the reason it still stands is because of a mirage of some 'reward' at the end of it all.
here is what i have to say; there is no purpose. this is all a lie. life is a joke, remember? laugh it off.
sab jhoot hai. sab jhoot.
mein bhee.
aur tum bhee.
'nuff said.
Post a Comment
<< Home