Saturday, June 17, 2006

Nausea

It's all the same. All of it. I keep browsing through all these blogs that are kept by my friends and acquaintances and random people, and they're all beginning to look the same. Postcolonialist debris in the form of deconstruction. A lot of "good" writers in Pakistan, (and I hate to sound like a pompous asshole), but a lot of "good" writers, including perhaps myself, in Pakistan, in the Subcontinent, are simply good at breaking down English, putting words, fragments of cultural lingo, Urdu, bits of reagional catch-phrases, and a ton of cliches in a blender, churning them all together and rearranging them in aesthetically fascinating patterns in their own "creations". This techinque may have started out great. It attracted with its novelty. It was, to put it simply, fun. It may even have had meaning and some threads of "substance". But the problem with "newness", is that it gets old real quick. I've been browsing through a bunch of blogs and I'm just about ready to throw up. It isn't that these writers aren't good. It isn't even the lack of meaning in what they write. Some of the stuff is exceptional when compared with others in the same genre, and the same breadth. But that's the problem. It's all in the same breath. They are all deconstructing language like each other, imbuing the same meanings into their works, all of them pretend to be covering up something deeply emotional behind a facade of elaborate metaphors and the "controlled" burst of vivid images(very much stinking of the bad breath of rigid empiricism). I'm nauseated by the string of personal experiences that are described in some of these works, very vividly, in much detail, with the pretence of one of two things: Either, that these experiences are somehow imbued with a deeper meaning on a higher level, or that they lack all deeper meaning and are simply there for the purpose of affiliation(More precisely, so that the individual who recounts them wants at the same time, to be able to capture the emotional/psychological dilemma of everybody else on earth, but still be able to stand out as an individual.) Some of them pride themselves on being absolutely meaningless: "I just write for myself and when I want to. I don't care what others make of it." Beware. Those are the ones who write precisely for others. And no matter how many times somebody tells you that what they've written isn't supposed to have some "greater" purpose or meaning, that isn't true. For they are aware,(I'm assuming they have something of the likes of a brain), that the simple act of putting up something they've written for the world to read, GIVES their work meaning of some sort. The simple act of their putting their thoughts, random, meaningless, or otherwise, on paper, is giving meaning or purpose to something.

If I am accused by the same accusations that I have made, I willingly step forward and take responsibility. We are a little too entrenched in what we are "supposed" to say and how we are "supposed" to say it. Not by superficial restrictions that others make for us, but by the restrictions we make for ourselves. By our conscious decisions to stick to the tried and tested: the comfortable.

If I have to kill a part of me in order to create a new part of me, then so be it. I'm not saying one more word, until the word justifies itself on paper. Until it has real reason to be there.

Yes, not everything has to have a reason. Or meaning. And it must not. But I NEED something different. I need to read, write and think something new. I need to. I'm sick of the sameness. It's beginning to clot inside me. I need fresh blood.

2 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

hmm...
before commenting i was thinking what should i be writing & for a moment i thought of not doing so but still...well i you've observed very rightly so...the sameness's there & other issues which you do have mentioned *though i do not tend to browse anonymous blogs that much*...but don't you think that many of them *excluding myself coz of an explicit reason* might have gone through same experiences *somewhat* hmm??

quoting "all of them pretend to be covering up something deeply emotional behind a facade of elaborate metaphors and the "controlled" burst of vivid images(very much stinking of the bad breath of rigid empiricism)."

for me this says all...it really does...i do conceal many things...i don't really know why do i write...for myself...for the masses or for any particular person & cause of this so called vague reason i have to write vague...saying it all won't & does not makes any sense *in most of the cases*...
lastly when i am quite fedup of this so called sameness i simply don't write anything...yes i am assured of one thing that i don't:)
btw thanks for changing few thoughts of mine...i owe ya for this i really do:)
gracias~

7:13 AM  
Blogger Aftab Iqbal said...

I remember ,a few years ago studying for my SAT Writing, the author said something of the sorts,"Keep it simple." That is how I believe language should be. There is no use of forcing words together just for the sake of a facade. Afterall, you want your stuff to be READ and the purpose of your writing FULFILLED. Most of the people in Pakistan use words lavishly. I think it has more to do with how our native language URDU is, full of words for the sake of words and not for the sake of purpose. We Pakistanis are obsessed with beautiful sentences and poems. Ghalib made a good effort in trying to make Urdu simple, especially through his letters.
Ever listen to debates in Pakistan, especially Urdu?? Full of words that sound good to the ear, but when you try to summarize in your mind what the debate was about, you can hardly write a paragraph.
So I guess, the English writing style of us Pakistani writers is a reflection of our culture. I don't blame the writers. Afterall, the mind does not know, what the eye does not see.
Some of them pride themselves on being absolutely meaningless: "I just write for myself and when I want to. I don't care what others make of it." Beware. Those are the ones who write precisely for others. And no matter how many times somebody tells you that what they've written isn't supposed to have some "greater" purpose or meaning, that isn't true

I don't know about the others, but I DO write for myself. And I also know the reason. You ever go through the feeling that you need to talk to someone, but there is noone there to listen?? I write in my blog because it is sort of my friend. A friend that always listens, is always there, and doesn't bombard me with its own problems :)

11:29 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home